Competence – In addition to being a competent social worker, you need to be a competent user of technology. First, the parents in this case essentially represent the client’s interests, and thus, their opinion is to be reckoned with. Importance of Human Relationship – Breaching a child’s confidentiality may impact their trust moving forward. Common examples involve a social worker’s response to a colleague who has behaved unethically or who is impaired or incompetent (the ethics of “whistle-blowing”). The National Association of Social Workers (NASW) Code of Ethics outlines these values, including service, social justice, dignity and worth of the person, importance of human relationships, integrity and competence. In both fields, highly trained professionals work directly with vulnerable populations. Social workers are of course bound to confidentiality, meaning they cannot discuss client business with anyone else. Most importantly, section 3 of the Children, Youth and Family Act (2005) unambiguously defines parents as the father and mother of the child (Victoria State Government 2017). Some years ago, prior to teaching in undergraduate social work, I was working with families and children in … Thus, the policies of both organisations provide the possibility for the girl’s parents to refuse hospital care and take their daughter home – under the condition that this decision could be considered the best possible option. Web. Like healthcare providers and HIPAA, this is a very serious matter that people lose their jobs over, even in the case of accidental breaches. These criteria can be interpreted both in favour of the parents’ and care providers’ positions. In addition, continued hospitalisation may disrupt the girl’s cultural environment, which may have an adverse effect on her overall well-being. Ethical Case Study Example All the sciences and studies relating to social and human problems oftentimes intersect and interrelate tightly. In addition, the claimed cultural justification of the decision may be crucial for Fern’s well-being, both to maintain her rights and to ensure the desired cultural and social environment. This situation is further elaborated in section 5.2.1 (b), which acknowledges the possibility of an exceptional situation where legal requirements and conditions or interests of other parties may outweigh the clients’ interests (AASW 2010). In this particular case, it is possible to imagine that I as a social worker would hold a firm belief that Fern’s parents have the ultimate right to bring her up at home regardless of possible risks, in which case I would support the parents’ decision. For example, if the cultural damage resulting from hospital care is considered significant, it would be rational to consider the opportunity of arranging a home-care program to mitigate the effect. In addition, the possibility remains that the cultural background of which Fern will be deprived could play an important part in her development as an individual. The complete list of the possibly affected parties is as follows: As mentioned above, numerous laws and regulations can be identified as relevant for the decision at hand. Royal Children’s Hospital 2013, The Australian charter of healthcare rights. The involvement of numerous stakeholders with different interests, values and goals often creates situations that demand resolution of complex decision-making processes. IvyPanda. The database is updated daily, so anyone can easily find a relevant essay example. Professional Ethics Case Example In the world of marriage and family therapy today, it is not uncommon to run into an ethical dilemma. hospital staff). Social Justice – Sometimes the law may seem unfair or your client’s situation may feel precarious, especially if he has experienced discrimination or injustice in the past. United Nations 1990, Convention on the rights of the child. In other words, regardless of the interests of the clinicians, Fern’s well-being will remain my only priority. 1.01 states that a social workers primary responsibility is to promote the wellbeing of clients. Human trafficking essay 100 words, format in making a case study my favourite bird parrot long essay in english. In this particular case, it will be necessary for me to ensure that Fern’s parents understand the consequences of their decision to withdraw her from the hospital and to achieve the best outcome for their child. Unfortunately, your browser is too old to work on this site. This is IvyPanda's free database of academic paper samples. Thompson ( 2006 ) describes favoritism as “ to place a difference and is non needfully a negative term ” . Again, Fern’s deteriorating condition suggests that the difference will be even more dramatic in the current situation, with her increased need for specialised medical care. Regardless of the preferred imperative, the deontological approach would make the choice more straightforward but less justified by the context of the case. These may experience indirect negative effects depending on the aftermath of the event. On the other hand, several risks are associated with this option. If you have a client that you continually use your traditional method, there is risk of allowing superficial talk. IvyPanda. This option has several notable advantages. The greatest disadvantage is the inability to satisfy the cultural expectations of the parents, which may potentially undermine the girl’s well-being (although no convincing evidence exists in favour of this assumption). Royal Children’s Hospital n.d., Patient rights responsibilities. As a person responsible for the right decision, a social worker will be held accountable once the adverse effects become apparent. Naturally, it thus becomes necessary to define what is considered “best” in Fern’s situation. In addition, the cultural environment may be compromised. In Fern’s case, it is also important to factor in her deteriorating physical condition and the suitability of the environment (in contrast to the conditions in her home). This is especially relevant in the case of Fern, whose developmental delays impair her capacity for decision-making (United Nations 1990). 1 - page 5 ... and 54%, respectively) to an ethical dilemma. According to its best-recognised definition, it aims at providing the greatest good for the greatest number (McAuliffe 2014). You are free to use it for research and reference purposes in order to write your own paper; however, you must. We are also beholden to the laws and policies of the agencies and communities we serve. Since Fern is unable to make decisions due to developmental delays, there is an apparent conflict of interest that clearly involves her well-being and presents no obvious solution. I consider it to be difficult to achieve since Fern cannot express herself, which means that her parents’ decision would take priority. There is only one scenario that justifies a breach of confidentiality, and reasonably so: unlawful and harmful acts. On the other hand, allowing her parents to take their daughter home is plausible, considering their right to make decisions for their child, but this course creates numerous health risks. Finally, this decision is consistent with the AASW Code of Ethics, which requires safeguarding the client’s rights and interests. Essay about business simulation. Both suggested courses of action pose several potentially hazardous outcomes for Fern. At the same time, Article 24 states the necessity to recognise the right of the child for the “highest attainable standard of health” and demands from States Parties to ensure that this right is maintained at all times (United Nations 1990). The Australian Charter of Healthcare Rights offers a similar approach by guaranteeing the possibility of service that respects the recipient’s culture and emphasises the right for inclusion in decisions of both the patients and their parents, with the latter having greater significance, considering Fern’s inability to express herself and make decisions (Royal Children’s Hospital 2013). Web. Need a custom Case Study sample written from scratch by Finally, the case makes it clear that the girl’s state improved dramatically after she was hospitalised in the past. July 30, 2020. https://ivypanda.com/essays/ethical-dilemmas-in-social-workers-practice/. case examples addresses the reality that ethical ... Journal of Social Work Values & Ethics, Spring 2013, Vol. These criteria align with the cultural and social implications. Next, it would be necessary to eliminate misinterpretation of the parental responsibility codified by Article 18 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, cited above. Web. When looking at subjugation from a Marxists position D’Amato claims that people are oppressed because of the category in which they live in, that adult females, homophiles or people of col… However, Article 18 of the same document prioritises the parents’ responsibility for the child’s development, thus granting them significant influence in the decision-making process. In this situation, people who have a chance for recovery will be rescued, and the rest will be left to die. With the upward trend in such cases, a closer look at the implications on social work practice and response would ensure that social workers are at the forefront of efforts to protect those vulnerable. How can you, as a busy practitioner or social work student, find the ti… Finally, I could try arranging scheduled meetings with her family to avoid disrupting cultural integrity.
Fender Deluxe Roadhouse Stratocaster Manual, Round Charcuterie Boards For Sale, Eurkitchen Whipped Cream Dispenser Parts, Amazon Virtual Internship 2020, Roses Saint Jhn Sheet Music, Butterfly Bushes For Sale Near Me, Grill Distance From Trex Railing, Kafka Streams Configuration, Nature Of Geography Meaning,